How to Disagree Without Being Disagreeable: A Spicy Conversation on Health Policies | Dr. Jessica Knurick, Dr. Will Cole, Jeff Krasno

WATCH THE FULL-LENGTH EPISODE HERE ON YOUTUBE! 

This episode is a little different. We recorded it live at the Eudemonia event with a simple goal: model what it looks like to have a hard conversation respectfully. Health has become politicized, and when that happens, we lose the ability to solve problems that are affecting real people every single day.

We start with the one thing we can all agree on: America is dealing with a chronic disease crisis. From a clinical lens, I see people doing “all the right things” and still struggling. That’s why I come back to the idea of an evolutionary mismatch, where our genes haven’t changed, but our food, stress load, environmental exposures, and lifestyles have changed dramatically in a short window of time.

At the same time, public health is about the population, not just the individual. Dr. Jessica brings the systems perspective: the environment most Americans live in is not designed for success, and social determinants shape health outcomes in a way that cannot be ignored. We talk through how policy, lobbying, and incentives influence food access, school meals, and the daily choices people can realistically make.

We also get into SNAP, dietary guidelines, and why trust in institutions gets complicated fast when nuance is stripped out. If you’ve felt overwhelmed by the noise, this episode is an invitation to slow down, stay curious, and do what we don’t do enough anymore: listen to understand.

A few of my favorite things we cover in this episode: 

• A live, on-stage conversation designed to model how to disagree respectfully, especially when health becomes politicized
• Chronic disease is the shared starting point, including “six in 10 Americans” with chronic disease and “four in 10” with multiple conditions
• Dr. Cole’s take on root causes: evolutionary mismatch, environmental toxins, stress, unresolved trauma, and why it’s a “perfect storm”
• Dr. Jessica’s systems lens: ultra processed food environment, movement guidelines, stress, sleep, and why “the environment is not set up for most people to succeed”
• Social determinants of health, poverty and chronic disease mapping, and why policy is inseparable from population health
• SNAP debate: food insecurity, program effectiveness, soda restriction trials, and modeling vs real-world outcomes
• Regulation vs downstream restrictions, and who should carry the true cost of chronic disease (including “externalizing costs”)
• Trust in science and institutions, FDA user fees context, and why nuance gets lost online
• Closing takeaway: listen to understand, seek connection, and take these skills into real-life conversations

Episode Sponsors:

• Go to bioptimizers.com/aobw and use my exclusive code AOBW to get 15% off any order. Make 2026 the year you finally start sleeping great again.
• 50% off your first year at monarch.com with code BEINGWELL.
• Visit fromourplace.com/WILLCOLE and use code WILLCOLE for 10% off site wide.
• Wake up with clearer skin, smoother hair, and cooler sleep. Use code WILLCOLE for an extra 30% off at blissy.com/WILLCOLE!
• Grab 30% off your first month of Mitopure Gummies at Timeline.com/WILLCOLE30.

Happy listening and we hope you learned a little bit more on the art of being well!

If you like what you hear, please rate and review the podcast, hit subscribe and pass it along to a friend.

In Health,

Dr. Will Cole